[Zubersoft]

Have you copied over a library backup file (Settings->Backup and Restore->Backup Library) and restored that on the new iPad? I would always recommend that as the first step before synchronizing as it ensures an identical database will be used on each device and also copies over the application settings. Is it necessary to do that? No, but I would like to know if it helps in this case as I'm not sure why the synchronization is not proceeding for you.

Mike